No racists need apply.
14-year-old Rebecca Fried wasn't planning to destroy the career of a college professor.
She was just avoiding her homework. As kids do.
Published in 2002 in the Journal of Social History, Jensen's "
Photo by Pattie (not Paddy) via Flickr.
At first, Rebecca she thought she was just missing something.
How could a simple Google search disprove an entire academic paper?

Image via Wikimedia Commons. Yes, it was that easy to find.
With her father's help, Rebecca reached out to Kerby Miller, a recently retired professor and Irish history scholar.

Photo by Cathal McNaughton/Getty Images
With Miller's help, Rebecca published her own academic rebuttal to Jensen's article.
Rebecca thanks Miller in her foreword for his guidance and notes, but as
And of course, Jensen had to defend himself.
When the news of Rebecca's publication hit IrishCentral.com, Jensen took to the comments section (the best place for serious academic discourse) to defend himself and get a few patronizing jabs in at his adolescent adversary.
The two went back and forth in the comments for a bit, with Rebecca showing her trademark maturity in her responses to him while also pointing out the central flaws in his thesis. Jensen, meanwhile, continued to insist that "No Irish need apply" was the result of mass delusion. But Rebecca rightly pointed out that the burden of proof should lay with him rather than on the collective cultural memory of an entire nation.
Not only did Jensen get the last word in in the comments section (because of course he did), but he's since published a formal rebuttal to her rebuttal as well (because of course he did).
GIF from "In Bruges."
Rebecca's paper shows what we can learn from history and how it's applicable even today.
So while you probably won't witness much Irish racism in 2015, the reverberations from that suffering surely still exist.
An actual illustration from a 19th-century scholarly text. Image via Wikimedia Commons.
By re-writing (or flat out denying) the shameful facts of discrimination, past or present, we make it easier for the same suffering to happen again and again.
Here's the real "Matrix"-level lesson-within-a-lesson: Being on the right side of history means not denying oppression in the now, as it continues to happen all around us. If instead we study the details of those past struggles, it might help illuminate some important truths about class, race, and power dynamics in the modern world.
In the meantime, we hope that Rebecca can survive the most oppressive part of human history: freshman year of high school.
Good luck, Rebecca. You're gonna need it.
I first found this story in The Daily Beast before it got picked up by Irish Central, and then it all started clicking in my head with stuff from these stories about Irish slavery/indentured servitude and the story of Frederick Douglass' Irish sojourn plus these horrible cartoons and this podcast about the Great Famine, which includes some awful lines from English politicians in the 1850s that sound identical to the kind of awful "welfare baby" rhetoric that racists use today, and then plus also every Pogues song ever and that time when I was six and my uncle from Belfast was going on about "Irish Catholic savages" and I asked my dad what he meant because we were Catholic ourselves, and, in my memory, this all happened around when he showed me "Blazing Saddles" for the first time, and I was equally confused by this scene because Little Thom obviously understood that skin-color racism = bad, but then so how come they didn't like Irish people, Daddy? I thought being Irish was cool; that's why we go to the parade and clap along to "Wild Rover"? And then just the other day, I was out at the pub and there was a British guy hitting on an Indian girl who was on a date with another girl, and he was talking about the great shame that befell his family when it was found out that his great-great-grandmother was Irish, and it was like soooooo many mindblowing levels of meta-colonialism that I was oh-so-very glad I had a beer in front of me (not to further perpetuate any negative stereotypes of my ancestry).
Oh, and the thumbnail image is by Frank Barratt/Keystone/Getty Images.

No comments:
Post a Comment